The Bank of England is seen in London, the United Kingdom, on Sept. 19, 2024.
(Getty Images)
The Bank of England is seen in London, the United Kingdom, on Sept. 19, 2024.

Prolonged market instability in the United Kingdom would force the government to implement more tax hikes or spending cuts that could derail key growth initiatives and heighten political pressures on the government. The U.K. government's borrowing costs have risen sharply over the past two weeks, with the yield on 10-year and 30-year government bonds climbing to 4.87% and 5.43% as of early trading on Jan. 14, respectively, each to their highest since 2008 and 1998. Meanwhile, the British pound dropped nearly 0.5% to $1.22 against the U.S. dollar on Jan. 14 (and nearly 2.5% since the start of 2025), its lowest level since November 2023. Speaking to Parliament on Jan. 9, Treasury Minister Darren Jones sought to reassure markets, asserting that U.K. bond markets ''continue to function in an orderly way'' despite recent pressures, and that ''underlying demand for the United Kingdom's debt remains strong.'' However, mounting criticism from British media and opposition parties has intensified pressure on Chancellor Rachel Reeves in recent days, prompting Prime Minister Keir Starmer to publicly back her on Jan. 13 by expressing ''full confidence'' in Reeves and dismissing speculation about her potential dismissal.

  • Reeves is set to deliver a budget update on March 26, coinciding with the release of official fiscal forecasts that will indicate whether her government is on track to achieve deficit reduction targets.

The recent sell-off in British assets reflects a combination of external and domestic factors, particularly a strong U.S. dollar and tightening global financial conditions, but also domestic vulnerabilities such as stagflation concerns and weakened investor confidence, raising questions over the U.K. government's fiscal credibility. A key driver behind the sell-off has been developments in the United States following Donald Trump's victory in the Nov. 5 presidential election. Projections for higher U.S. inflation, fuelled by the incoming Trump administration's tariff-driven agenda and supported by strong U.S. economic data, have prompted markets to scale back their expectations for Federal Reserve interest rate cuts in 2025. This has strengthened the U.S. dollar and, attracting capital inflows, pushed U.S. Treasury yields higher, thus causing borrowing costs to rise globally. While these dynamics have heightened concerns over debt sustainability worldwide, the United Kingdom is particularly vulnerable due to recent economic and inflation data pointing to a stagflationary outlook for the coming months, while business and investor sentiment has deteriorated following Reeves's tax hikes and borrowing plans in her Oct. 30 Autumn Budget. This has drawn comparisons to the 2022 ''mini-budget'' crisis that ultimately led to the resignation of former Prime Minister Liz Truss. Yet the current sell-off has so far been less severe, as markets view Reeves's policies as substantially more cautious than Truss's, despite concerns over limited fiscal headroom; there is also no sign yet of the type of institutional investor strain that had prompted the Bank of England's emergency bond purchases under Truss. Nevertheless, the situation remains precarious, with the government's fiscal credibility increasingly under scrutiny and the potential for further market disruptions.

  • The U.S. dollar has appreciated significantly against all major currencies over the past two months, with markets now expecting the Fed to implement just one quarter-point interest rate cut this year. The U.S. Dollar Index (DXY), which measures the dollar's value relative to a basket of currencies, increased from approximately 108.1 on Nov. 5 to around 109.6 on Jan. 10, marking a rise of about 1.5%. 
  • Although more pronounced, the rise in U.K. government bond yields is broadly in line with those of its peers. Over the same period, 10-year and 30-year gilt yields increased by 32 and 30.7 basis points, respectively, compared with 27 and 24.1 basis points for France, 30 and 23.5 for Italy, 25 and 21.7 for Germany (Europe's benchmark), and 23 and 20.1 for the United States, exceeding the average by 5 and 7 basis points, according to Bloomberg data. This suggests the sharp rise is mostly due to movements in global financial markets, with only limited contribution from idiosyncratic British fiscal policy factors.
  • The sell-off in British assets also follows weeks of negative economic developments in the United Kingdom, with data from the Office for National Statistics showing annual inflation hitting an eight-month high of 2.6% in November, up from 2.3% in October, and the economy growing by just 0.1% in the third quarter of 2024 after expanding by 0.5% in the previous one. 
  • Additionally, business sentiment has deteriorated since Reeves announced 40 billion pounds worth of tax hikes during her Autumn Statement on Oct. 30, while investors were further unsettled by Reeves's plans to borrow 140 billion pounds — far exceeding market expectations — to fund public services and infrastructure projects. Under the new budget, the U.K. government deficit is projected to reach 4.5% of GDP in the 2024/25 fiscal year, slightly lower than last year's 4.8% but still higher than planned by the previous government as part of fiscal consolidation efforts. Rising borrowing costs risk further driving up this ratio. 
  • Investors will closely watch U.K. inflation data due to be released on Jan. 15, with a potential substantial increase likely to drive bond yields further up.

Should yields rise sharply or market pressures persist, it would indicate a loss of investor confidence in the ruling Labour Party's fiscal strategy, forcing policy adjustments that could jeopardize pre-election growth targets, hinder key initiatives and intensify political pressures on an increasingly unpopular government. Should yields rise sharply relative to the United States and the eurozone, it would indicate waning investor confidence in the Labour government's economic strategy and fiscal plans, forcing Reeves (or whoever will be in her post by then) to impose spending cuts or tax hikes to restore fiscal credibility and reassure markets. Even if market pressures persist without a short-term rise in yields — driven primarily by exogenous forces and not directly implying a loss of market confidence in Reeves's fiscal policy — the combination of a weakening pound and soaring borrowing costs could hinder the Bank of England's ability to lower interest rates, deepening economic stagnation and reducing Reeves's already narrow fiscal headspace, again forcing the government to adjust policy. Further tax hikes and spending cuts would greatly reduce the chances of the government meeting Labour's ambitious pre-election growth targets and pledges to revitalize ailing public services in the United Kingdom, likely eroding the ruling party's public approval and intensifying political pressures on the government. Should U.K. economic growth then continue to stagnate for the medium term, limited fiscal space would deter the government from implementing significant fiscal stimulus, which would likely take resources away from initiatives like boosting investment in infrastructure, industrial innovation and renewable energy, thus hindering or delaying progress on key government goals like addressing housing shortages, accelerating the energy transition and boosting productivity.

  • The Labour government has set an ambitious target of achieving an average annual GDP growth rate of 2.5%. Since the global financial crisis in 2009, however, the United Kingdom has recorded a modest average annual growth rate of just 1.5%. Despite the country's growing labor market, productivity growth (measured as average output per hour) has been limited to 0.5% per year, making it the second slowest among G-7 nations, ahead of only Italy.
  • The government has pledged to reduce public debt as a share of GDP, which the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) estimates at 98.4% of GDP for 2024, over the next five years. At the same time, it has committed to raising public spending to enhance living standards and improve public services. Reeves outlined a 70 billion pound annual increase in public spending in her Oct. 30 Autumn Budget, funded through a combination of tax hikes and additional borrowing. The government has also promised to expand the national power grid, construct 1.5 million new homes, and hire more teachers, doctors and police officers, with the Labour Party arguing in its pre-election manifesto that economic growth, rather than tax increases, would generate the additional revenue needed to finance these ambitious initiatives.
  • The OBR forecasts the United Kingdom's net debt to decrease from 98.4% of GDP in 2024 to about 97.1% by the end of the decade, but rising borrowing costs could make this goal harder to achieve, with the OBR set to release new estimates at the end of March.
  • A YouGov/Times poll released on Jan. 13 highlighted the political challenges already facing Starmer's government, with Labour's support dropping to just 26% since the July 4, 2024, election. The same poll showed Nigel Farage's right-wing Reform U.K. party surging to second place with 25% support, followed by the Conservative Party with 22%.
RANE
SUBSCRIBERS ONLY

Expert analysis when it matters most.

Get access to RANE's decision-grade geopolitical intelligence.